Performance Review 2017-2019
NAMMCO agreed in 2017 to undertake a Performance Review of the organisation based on the “Kobe Criteria for Reviewing the Performance of RFMOs” and amended to reflect NAMMCO’s mandate and membership.
The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), the International Whaling Commission (IWC) and the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Organization (NAFO) were each asked to nominate a member of the Performance Review Panel, and the members of the Panel were: Dan Goodman, FAO nominee, Caterina Fortuna, IWC nominee and chair of the Panel and Russell Smith, NAFO nominee.
The report, presented to the 27th Council meeting in 2019, concluded that the Commission meets its objective stated in the NAMMCO Agreement by contributing “through regional consultation and cooperation to the conservation, rational management and study of marine mammals in the North Atlantic“. It underlined that outputs from NAMMCO Committees had been significant and substantial, and that NAMMCO had attained a level of credibility among other organisations involved with Arctic issues and marine mammal conservation. Its work was valued, relied upon and sought and NAMMCO was a preeminent and credible forum for the discussion on conservation and management of marine mammals in the Arctic and Northern Atlantic regions.
The Panel found that all NAMMCO members share NAMMCO’s commitment to ensure the sustainable management of marine mammals in the North Atlantic. They had, for the most part, implemented the recommendations and the conservation and management measures proposed by the Commission in a timely fashion, although there have been some instances in which they had not.
The Panel concluded that while NAMMCO had performed well, there was room for improvement, and it provided a total of 95 specific recommendations and suggestions on how the Commission could improve various aspects of its performance and had identified some serious concerns.
NAMMCO established an ad hoc Working Group (PRWG) led by the Chair of Council to review the recommendations introduced in the Performance Review Report.
Discussing NAMMCO policies and principles in general and noting the over-arching recommendations from the Panel, the PRWG identified five issues that would further strengthening and improving the work of the organisation, both in the shorter and longer terms. These were:
1) Data quality and reliability to ensure high quality science, which is at the core of NAMMCO management,
2) Follow up on the scientific, conservation and management advice provided by the Committees,
3) Transparency in work processes,
4) Precautionary approach in management,
5) Communication efforts.
All NAMMCO Committees and working groups were asked to review the recommendations specific to their areas of work in light of these five issues.
The committees overall respnse was to underline the importance of and need for: a) the website to serve as a hub of reliable information (for both internaluse and for the public), b) reliable data reporting from Member Countries, c) a standardised manner of reporting all data requests, and) the safe storage of data on a suitable platform to ensure standardisation, continuity, and accessibility.
Concluding its work the PRWG agreed that the Performance Review had been a positive process for assessing the progress and priorities of the organisation. It had confirmed that NAMMCO outputs were substantial and substantive and made it a credible forum for discussion of the conservation and management of marine mammals in the Arctic and North Atlantic regions.
The PRWG recommended Council to adopt a set of follow up actions for each of the five priority issues identified for NAMMCO, which could benefit from greater attention and focus.
You can find the report of the Performance Review Panel here.
Performance Review documents .zip file and report
Individual documents can be downloaded below.
PRP2018_01 – List of Annual reports and information on the Council meetings, Committee meetings and National Progress reports they cover/refer to, with information on Chairs and including adoption of and changes to RoPs, Rules & Strategies.
PRP2018_02 – Time line of events/activities/main decisions
PRP 2018 03 – List of key people in NAMMCO
PRP2018_04 – SC: Historic: SC Members & Participants to Annual meeting (all)
PRP2018_05 – Overview of international legal instruments pertaining to the NAMMCO area of competence
PRP2018_06 – Background information on the “Nuuk Declaration”: details for each of the 5 bullet points (paragraph 2) with specific examples
PRP2018_07 – Overview of ToRs for WG, EG, WS, Symposia and conferences organised by NAMMCO
PRP2018_09 – List of all advices provided to the Council/Management Committees (MCs) by the Scientific Committee (SC) until CN24, decision by Council/MCs, and answers by Parties
PRP2018_10 – List of all advices provided to the Council/Management Committees (MCs) by the Scientific Committee (SC) since CN25, decision by Council/MCs, and answers by Parties
PRP2018_11 – List of requests of advice from Council to the Scientific Committee and Scientific Committee responses.
PRP2018_12 – List of all advices provided to the Council/Management Committees (MCs) by the Committee of Hunting Methods (CHM), decision by Council/MCs, and answers by Parties
PRP2018_13 – List of all advices provided to the Council/Management Committees (MCs) by the Committee on Inspection and Observation (CIO), decision by Council/MCs, and answers by Parties
PRP2018_14-DUPLICATE given in PRP2018_09
PRP2018_15-DUPLICATE given in PRP2018_10
PRP2018_16 – CHM: Overview of Marine Mammal Hunting Methods, inc. national regulations & monitoring/observations in NAMMCO countries
PRP2018_17 – Overview of hunt types in NAMMCO countries and hunts observed in 1998-2017
PRP2018_18 – CHM: Information on the Norwegian blue box (a. doc to IWC 2005, b. doc to NAMMCO EG – evaluation 2010)
PRP2018_19 – DUPLICATE given in PRP2018_20 (CIO: Overview of observation activities (incl. target hunts and efforts))
PRP2018_20_CIO: Overview & Evaluation of the implementation of the NAMMCO Control Scheme by Secretariat (after CIO meeting in February 2018)
PRP2018_21 – DUPLICATE given in PRP2018_20 (CIO: A summary of the activities undertaken under the NAMMCO control scheme.)
PRP2018_23 – Overview of the conservation status of marine mammal stocks in-NAMMCO countries and relevant national regulations
PRP2018_24 – DUPLICATE of PRP2018_23 (Overview of the conservation status of marine mammal stocks in NAMMCO countries)
PRP2018_25 – Marine mammals in the purview of NAMMCO
PRP2018_26 – Reviews and assessments of cetacean stocks by NAMMCO
PRP2018_27 – Comments from reviews and assessments of cetacean stocks by NAMMCO
PRP2018_28 – Reviews and assessments of pinniped stocks by NAMMCO
PRP2018_29 – Comments from reviews and assessments of pinniped stocks by NAMMCO
PRP2018_30 – Trends of Cetacean Abundance
PRP2018_31 – Trends of Seal Abundance
PRP2018_32 – NAMMCO Catch Database
Overview of participation of observers to NAMMCO Council meetings
PRP2018_34 – List of organizations with whom there has been cooperation with NAMMCO on scientific issues
PRP2018_35 – NAMMCO Secretariat participation/cooperation with other organizations including Regional Fishery Body Secretariats Network, FAO, OSPAR, NEAFC and others
PRP2018_36 – ICES-NAMMCO relationship, developments from MOU to LOA and joint WG
PRP2018_37 – List of organizations to which NAMMCO members are appointed as observers on behalf of NAMMCO
PRP2018_38 – DUPLICATE of PRP2018_34 (Discussion with ASCOBANS on a cooperation on a status review of harbour porpoises in the North Atlantic)
PRP2018_39 – A chronology of activities undertaken by NAMMCO related to public information/communications.
PRP2018_40 – Review and list of NAMMCO contacts with media, politicians, IGOs and NGOs and educational institutions, including list of sought contacts and object and the list of citations of NAMMCO work 2013-18 (citation of reports) in in different forum (academic, IUCN red list assessments, IWC, CAFF, DFO-COSEWIC, ICES, SCOS reports, NGOs)
PRP2018_41 – A list or summary of the major actions undertaken by the NAMMCO council related to finance and administration. [PRP2018_01 as well as [events-timeline.xlsx]
PRP2018_42 – A description of the Secretariat staff and the responsibilities of the various positions
PRP2018_43 – Overview on NAMMCO budget and changes in the allocations of funds
PRP2018_44 – Specification on budget cuts in budget 2018-20
PRP2018_45 – Overview of work load through the years for the Scientific Committee versus the Committee for Hunting Methods, Committee for Inspection and Observation and the Working Group on By-catch, Entanglements and Live Strandings (BYCELS)
PRP2018_46 – Overview of pension costs 2012-2018
Overview of human resources Parties devote to the work of NAMMCO